Man-handling an old man
Posted By: 'cause he's anti-war? see msg on 2005-09-29
In Reply to:
This is what it has come to? Bush lapdog Blair takes a tip from American repugs so that even an old man gets abused for being a dissenting voice in this senseless war? How disgraceful is that?! At least they've got egg on their faces because of it and had to apologize.
Stifling Iraq dissent backfires for Labour
Thu Sep 29, 2005 2:51 PM BST
By Katherine Baldwin
BRIGHTON (Reuters) - Tony Blair apologised on Thursday to an 82-year-old man ejected from the annual conference of his Labour Party for heckling over Iraq, catapulting the divisive war back into the headlines.
The heavy-handed removal of Walter Wolfgang on Wednesday backfired for the Labour leadership, with some delegates saying it reflected an internal climate which put too much emphasis on maintaining control and silencing dissent.
You cannot stifle debate by hiring heavies, said Wolfgang, who received a hero's welcome as he returned to conference.
We made a mistake, I believe, in invading Iraq without cause. We've got to rectify it by withdrawing from Iraq. If you try to ignore it, it will not go away, he said.
Wolfgang's expulsion was splashed across the front pages of several national newspapers and dominated the news on the final day of the meeting in Brighton.
This indicates a wider culture of control and intolerance of dissent, said David Clark, a former adviser to the late Robin Cook, one of Labour's most prominent opponents of the war.
But Defence Secretary John Reid, who also apologised to Wolfgang, insisted Labour had a culture of being able to debate controversial subjects such as Iraq without questioning other people's integrity or sincerity.
Anger over the decision to back the 2003 U.S.-led invasion split Labour and Britain and continues to dog Blair.
Analysts say the prime minister's fate is inextricably linked to events in Iraq, where British troops came under heavy attack this month and elections are set for December.
Blair won a third straight term in May but opposition to the war contributed to a slide in Labour's parliamentary majority.
The prime minister has said he will not run in an expected 2009 election but he seems keen to stay for several years before he is expected to hand over to Chancellor Gordon Brown.
Burly stewards grabbed Wolfgang and bundled him out of the conference on Wednesday after he interrupted Foreign Secretary Jack Straw as he said British troops were in Iraq to help build a secure and stable country and would stay as long as needed.
That's a lie and you know it ... Rubbish, shouted Wolfgang, a refugee from Nazi Germany and a party member for 57 years.
Wolfgang was briefly arrested using anti-terrorism powers.
People are perfectly entitled to freedom of speech in our country ... and I'm really sorry about what happened to Walter and I've apologised to him, Blair told the BBC.
Complete Discussion Below:  marks the location of current message within thread
The messages you are viewing
are archived/old.
To view latest messages and participate in discussions, select
the boards given in left menu
Other related messages found in our database
Shame on you. I think he is handling this exactly right. nm
.
Agree; OBama's handling of this was excellent.
Now is the news media and political pundits would just leave it alone ...
I actually heard someone a bit ago on TV say "..makes you question her parenting skills if her daughter is pregnant". I just about threw a pillow at the TV!
|
