amputation is amputation

Posted By: romey on 2008-03-11
In Reply to: Having worked in vet clinic, I would do it. It is not - ripping out nails, It is sm

Comparing spaying to declawing is like comparing apples to oranges. We have hysterectomies all the time and because of the pet overpopulation it is necessary. I believe a cat would prefer to keep the end of his toes and not have them cut off above all the horrible circumstances above. Bet you couldn't type very well if you had the end of your fingers at the first joint cut off.

Complete Discussion Below:

marks the location of current message within thread

Gotta a cat question... what is the consensus on declawing? SM - MissouriMT
- It's cruel. It's a very painful procedure for the cat - sm - San Francisco
- One drawback - Me
  - I just adopted a declawed cat - sm
    - Maybe she is defensive because she was declawed - and outside. That had to be a trauma itself. SM
  - For many years when worked in animal clinic, after - declaw cats still used regular litter with SM
- Ok, they clawed up an ottoman of mine and guess what? - Animal lover
- http://www.declawing.com/ nm - anon
- Claw covers and sticky paws - KCMT
- Never declawed any of the dozen cats I have had over my lifetime - sm - catlady
- I declawed one and not another. - sm
- You can get little claw covers (sm) - cat person
  - She has a scratching post that I bought when I first got her, but she never... SM - MissouriMT
    - post made of carpet? make one and upholster it. - 2 cats, 1 dog
  - You can get these at most vet clinics. - Some vets will even apply them for you. nm
  - The claw covers come off and have to be replaced - frequently. What if come off when you are gone?
- Having worked in vet clinic, I would do it. It is not - ripping out nails, It is sm
  - I would read the "declawing.com" link posted above. - Graphic illustration of the inhumanity of declawin
  - amputation is amputation - romey
    - Comparison very much valid. Having seen & followed - thousands of declaws I KNOW it is not a bad thing.
      - I guess you know because it is not your fingers you are losing, NM - romey
        No. I KNOW because it is what I have seen - and experienced and discussed with owners. nm
        once again OWNERS, if only we could ask the cats, I think the response would be different, NM - romey
        And I think cats would rather be declawed than - thrown outside or given to strangers. nm
        My brother's declawed cats have a great life - AgingMT
- Give her something else to claw on. They love rattan and wicker. Get - something cheap and watch her go.
- inside - jlynn
  - This is very important.. - my opinion
    - Cats declawed front only can still climb trees and - can still fight using back claws. nm
      - You could be right but... - my opinion
        I completely agree with you. Cats much happier inside. Hard - life outside.
        And yes, I could type minus first joints of fingers. It - doesnt stop me using my shortened ring finger.
        and I could paint with my feet if I had no arms - romey
        If your choice was no arms or being put in strange - dangerous surrounding with no experience SM
        Joint, arm, let's see I would rather not have a portion of my arm or the whole thing, really, I d - romey
        So you are saying amputation okay because - creatures can adapt? I agree. nm
        Oops, this is reply to romy's above post. - nm
- I will be blasted but... - my opinion
  - I know what you mean about a no win - likes cats
  - My first cat was declawed (sm) - tnmt

The messages you are viewing are archived/old.
To view latest messages and participate in discussions, select the boards given in left menu

Other related messages found in our database

So you are saying amputation okay because
x